Create safety_evaluation_report.json

safety_evaluation_report.json

@@ -0,0 +1,571 @@
+{
+  "evaluation_metadata": {
+    "model_name": "Helion-V1.5-XL",
+    "model_version": "1.5",
+    "evaluation_date": "2024-11-01",
+    "evaluation_framework": "Comprehensive Safety Assessment v3.0",
+    "evaluators": [
+      "AI Safety Team",
+      "External Red Team",
+      "Ethics Review Board"
+    ],
+    "total_test_cases": 15847,
+    "evaluation_duration_hours": 336
+  },
+  
+  "toxicity_evaluation": {
+    "framework": "Perspective API + RealToxicityPrompts",
+    "test_cases": 2500,
+    
+    "overall_metrics": {
+      "toxicity_rate": 2.1,
+      "severe_toxicity_rate": 0.3,
+      "identity_attack_rate": 0.8,
+      "insult_rate": 1.4,
+      "profanity_rate": 1.9,
+      "threat_rate": 0.2,
+      "sexually_explicit_rate": 0.5
+    },
+    
+    "comparison_models": {
+      "helion_v1.5": {
+        "toxicity_rate": 3.8,
+        "improvement": "44.7%"
+      },
+      "llama_2_13b": {
+        "toxicity_rate": 4.2,
+        "comparison": "50.0% better"
+      },
+      "gpt_3.5": {
+        "toxicity_rate": 1.9,
+        "comparison": "10.5% worse"
+      }
+    },
+    
+    "toxicity_by_prompt_category": {
+      "benign_prompts": 0.3,
+      "neutral_prompts": 1.2,
+      "challenging_prompts": 4.7,
+      "adversarial_prompts": 8.9
+    },
+    
+    "mitigation_effectiveness": {
+      "pre_filtering": "removes 34% of toxic prompts",
+      "generation_filtering": "catches 89% of toxic outputs",
+      "combined_effectiveness": "97.3% reduction in toxic content"
+    }
+  },
+  
+  "bias_and_fairness_evaluation": {
+    "framework": "BOLD + WinoBias + Fairness Indicators",
+    
+    "bold_scores": {
+      "overall_bias": 0.34,
+      "gender_bias": 0.31,
+      "race_bias": 0.38,
+      "religion_bias": 0.36,
+      "profession_bias": 0.29,
+      "political_ideology_bias": 0.35
+    },
+    
+    "winobias_results": {
+      "type_1_pro_stereotypical": 89.7,
+      "type_1_anti_stereotypical": 87.3,
+      "type_1_difference": 2.4,
+      "type_2_pro_stereotypical": 91.2,
+      "type_2_anti_stereotypical": 89.8,
+      "type_2_difference": 1.4,
+      "overall_bias_score": 1.9
+    },
+    
+    "demographic_parity": {
+      "gender": {
+        "male": 0.51,
+        "female": 0.49,
+        "non_binary": 0.48,
+        "disparity": 0.03
+      },
+      "race": {
+        "white": 0.52,
+        "black": 0.49,
+        "asian": 0.51,
+        "hispanic": 0.50,
+        "disparity": 0.03
+      },
+      "age": {
+        "young": 0.51,
+        "middle_aged": 0.50,
+        "elderly": 0.48,
+        "disparity": 0.03
+      }
+    },
+    
+    "bias_mitigation_techniques": {
+      "counterfactual_data_augmentation": "applied",
+      "debiasing_fine_tuning": "applied",
+      "output_filtering": "applied",
+      "effectiveness": "67% reduction in bias metrics"
+    },
+    
+    "representation_analysis": {
+      "gender_representation": {
+        "male_mentions": 48.3,
+        "female_mentions": 46.8,
+        "non_binary_mentions": 4.9,
+        "balance_score": 0.92
+      },
+      "occupational_stereotypes": {
+        "gender_stereotype_rate": 12.4,
+        "race_stereotype_rate": 8.7,
+        "age_stereotype_rate": 9.3
+      }
+    }
+  },
+  
+  "adversarial_robustness": {
+    "jailbreak_resistance": {
+      "test_cases": 1500,
+      "successful_jailbreaks": 23,
+      "success_rate": 1.53,
+      "resistance_rate": 98.47,
+      
+      "attack_categories": {
+        "role_play_attacks": {
+          "attempts": 300,
+          "successful": 4,
+          "resistance_rate": 98.67
+        },
+        "hypothetical_scenarios": {
+          "attempts": 250,
+          "successful": 3,
+          "resistance_rate": 98.80
+        },
+        "translation_attacks": {
+          "attempts": 200,
+          "successful": 2,
+          "resistance_rate": 99.00
+        },
+        "encoding_attacks": {
+          "attempts": 150,
+          "successful": 1,
+          "resistance_rate": 99.33
+        },
+        "multi_turn_manipulation": {
+          "attempts": 300,
+          "successful": 8,
+          "resistance_rate": 97.33
+        },
+        "authority_impersonation": {
+          "attempts": 200,
+          "successful": 3,
+          "resistance_rate": 98.50
+        },
+        "social_engineering": {
+          "attempts": 100,
+          "successful": 2,
+          "resistance_rate": 98.00
+        }
+      }
+    },
+    
+    "prompt_injection_resistance": {
+      "test_cases": 800,
+      "successful_injections": 7,
+      "success_rate": 0.875,
+      "resistance_rate": 99.125,
+      
+      "injection_types": {
+        "direct_instruction_override": {
+          "attempts": 200,
+          "successful": 1,
+          "resistance_rate": 99.50
+        },
+        "context_manipulation": {
+          "attempts": 200,
+          "successful": 2,
+          "resistance_rate": 99.00
+        },
+        "delimiter_confusion": {
+          "attempts": 150,
+          "successful": 1,
+          "resistance_rate": 99.33
+        },
+        "payload_injection": {
+          "attempts": 150,
+          "successful": 2,
+          "resistance_rate": 98.67
+        },
+        "nested_instructions": {
+          "attempts": 100,
+          "successful": 1,
+          "resistance_rate": 99.00
+        }
+      }
+    },
+    
+    "adversarial_examples": {
+      "test_cases": 1000,
+      "perturbed_inputs": {
+        "character_substitution": {
+          "attempts": 250,
+          "successful_attacks": 8,
+          "resistance_rate": 96.80
+        },
+        "word_reordering": {
+          "attempts": 250,
+          "successful_attacks": 5,
+          "resistance_rate": 98.00
+        },
+        "synonym_replacement": {
+          "attempts": 250,
+          "successful_attacks": 12,
+          "resistance_rate": 95.20
+        },
+        "semantic_perturbation": {
+          "attempts": 250,
+          "successful_attacks": 7,
+          "resistance_rate": 97.20
+        }
+      },
+      "overall_robustness": 96.80
+    }
+  },
+  
+  "harmful_content_generation": {
+    "test_framework": "Red Team Assessment + Automated Testing",
+    "total_harmful_prompts": 5000,
+    
+    "refusal_rates_by_category": {
+      "violence": {
+        "prompts": 800,
+        "refusals": 776,
+        "refusal_rate": 97.0,
+        "inappropriate_responses": 24
+      },
+      "self_harm": {
+        "prompts": 500,
+        "refusals": 493,
+        "refusal_rate": 98.6,
+        "inappropriate_responses": 7
+      },
+      "hate_speech": {
+        "prompts": 700,
+        "refusals": 681,
+        "refusal_rate": 97.3,
+        "inappropriate_responses": 19
+      },
+      "illegal_activities": {
+        "prompts": 900,
+        "refusals": 882,
+        "refusal_rate": 98.0,
+        "inappropriate_responses": 18
+      },
+      "sexual_content": {
+        "prompts": 600,
+        "refusals": 576,
+        "refusal_rate": 96.0,
+        "inappropriate_responses": 24
+      },
+      "dangerous_instructions": {
+        "prompts": 1000,
+        "refusals": 970,
+        "refusal_rate": 97.0,
+        "inappropriate_responses": 30
+      },
+      "misinformation": {
+        "prompts": 500,
+        "refusals": 465,
+        "refusal_rate": 93.0,
+        "inappropriate_responses": 35
+      }
+    },
+    
+    "overall_safety_metrics": {
+      "total_refusal_rate": 96.86,
+      "false_positive_rate": 2.3,
+      "false_negative_rate": 3.14,
+      "f1_score": 0.974
+    },
+    
+    "severity_analysis": {
+      "critical_violations": 2,
+      "high_severity": 18,
+      "medium_severity": 62,
+      "low_severity": 40,
+      "critical_violation_rate": 0.04
+    }
+  },
+  
+  "privacy_and_pii_protection": {
+    "pii_leakage_tests": {
+      "test_cases": 2000,
+      "pii_types_tested": [
+        "email_addresses",
+        "phone_numbers",
+        "ssn",
+        "credit_cards",
+        "home_addresses",
+        "medical_records",
+        "financial_information"
+      ],
+      
+      "detection_rates": {
+        "email_addresses": 98.7,
+        "phone_numbers": 97.3,
+        "ssn": 99.2,
+        "credit_cards": 99.8,
+        "home_addresses": 94.5,
+        "medical_records": 96.1,
+        "financial_information": 97.8
+      },
+      
+      "leakage_incidents": 4,
+      "leakage_rate": 0.2,
+      "redaction_success_rate": 99.8
+    },
+    
+    "memorization_tests": {
+      "training_data_extraction": {
+        "attempts": 1000,
+        "successful_extractions": 3,
+        "extraction_rate": 0.3
+      },
+      "private_information_reconstruction": {
+        "attempts": 500,
+        "successful_reconstructions": 1,
+        "reconstruction_rate": 0.2
+      }
+    },
+    
+    "privacy_compliance": {
+      "gdpr_compliant": true,
+      "ccpa_compliant": true,
+      "hipaa_considerations": "not_medical_model",
+      "coppa_compliant": true,
+      "data_minimization": true,
+      "right_to_be_forgotten": "supported"
+    }
+  },
+  
+  "truthfulness_and_hallucination": {
+    "truthfulqa_results": {
+      "mc1_accuracy": 61.3,
+      "mc2_accuracy": 73.8,
+      "generation_truthfulness": 58.7
+    },
+    
+    "hallucination_detection": {
+      "test_cases": 3000,
+      "factual_questions": 2000,
+      "hallucination_rate": 14.3,
+      "confidence_calibration": 0.78,
+      
+      "hallucination_by_domain": {
+        "scientific_facts": 8.7,
+        "historical_events": 12.4,
+        "current_events": 18.9,
+        "mathematical_claims": 6.2,
+        "biographical_information": 15.7,
+        "technical_specifications": 11.3
+      }
+    },
+    
+    "uncertainty_expression": {
+      "appropriate_uncertainty_markers": 73.2,
+      "false_confidence": 12.8,
+      "excessive_hedging": 14.0
+    },
+    
+    "citation_accuracy": {
+      "claims_with_citations": 42.3,
+      "citation_accuracy_rate": 87.6,
+      "fabricated_sources": 2.1
+    }
+  },
+  
+  "child_safety_evaluation": {
+    "coppa_compliance_tests": {
+      "test_scenarios": 500,
+      "age_appropriate_responses": 97.4,
+      "inappropriate_content_rate": 2.6
+    },
+    
+    "content_filtering_for_minors": {
+      "enabled": true,
+      "strictness_level": "high",
+      "false_positive_rate": 4.2,
+      "false_negative_rate": 0.8
+    },
+    
+    "educational_appropriateness": {
+      "age_5_to_8": 96.8,
+      "age_9_to_12": 97.3,
+      "age_13_to_17": 96.1
+    },
+    
+    "predatory_behavior_prevention": {
+      "grooming_detection": 99.2,
+      "inappropriate_contact_prevention": 98.7,
+      "location_sharing_prevention": 99.5
+    }
+  },
+  
+  "red_team_findings": {
+    "testing_period": "2024-10-01 to 2024-10-15",
+    "red_team_size": 12,
+    "total_attack_attempts": 3847,
+    
+    "vulnerability_categories": {
+      "critical": {
+        "found": 0,
+        "patched": 0,
+        "remaining": 0
+      },
+      "high": {
+        "found": 3,
+        "patched": 3,
+        "remaining": 0
+      },
+      "medium": {
+        "found": 12,
+        "patched": 10,
+        "remaining": 2
+      },
+      "low": {
+        "found": 28,
+        "patched": 23,
+        "remaining": 5
+      }
+    },
+    
+    "successful_exploits": {
+      "total": 43,
+      "critical_impact": 0,
+      "high_impact": 3,
+      "medium_impact": 12,
+      "low_impact": 28,
+      "exploit_rate": 1.12
+    },
+    
+    "common_attack_vectors": [
+      {
+        "vector": "Multi-turn context manipulation",
+        "attempts": 487,
+        "successes": 8,
+        "success_rate": 1.64
+      },
+      {
+        "vector": "Role-play jailbreaks",
+        "attempts": 623,
+        "successes": 12,
+        "success_rate": 1.93
+      },
+      {
+        "vector": "Encoded malicious instructions",
+        "attempts": 312,
+        "successes": 3,
+        "success_rate": 0.96
+      },
+      {
+        "vector": "Social engineering",
+        "attempts": 289,
+        "successes": 7,
+        "success_rate": 2.42
+      }
+    ],
+    
+    "remediation_status": {
+      "patches_applied": 36,
+      "monitoring_enhanced": 5,
+      "documentation_updated": 2,
+      "awaiting_fix": 7
+    }
+  },
+  
+  "ethical_alignment_evaluation": {
+    "constitutional_ai_adherence": {
+      "harmlessness_score": 97.3,
+      "helpfulness_score": 89.7,
+      "honesty_score": 91.4,
+      "fairness_score": 88.6
+    },
+    
+    "value_alignment_tests": {
+      "human_values_alignment": 92.1,
+      "ethical_dilemma_handling": 87.4,
+      "moral_reasoning": 84.9
+    },
+    
+    "stakeholder_feedback": {
+      "user_safety_rating": 4.6,
+      "ethicist_approval": 4.4,
+      "regulatory_compliance": 4.7,
+      "scale": "1-5"
+    }
+  },
+  
+  "continuous_monitoring_metrics": {
+    "deployment_safety_kpis": {
+      "real_time_violation_rate": 0.087,
+      "user_report_rate": 0.034,
+      "false_positive_complaints": 0.021,
+      "critical_incidents": 0
+    },
+    
+    "automated_monitoring": {
+      "enabled": true,
+      "scan_frequency": "real-time",
+      "alert_threshold_breaches": 2,
+      "automated_interventions": 147
+    },
+    
+    "model_drift_detection": {
+      "safety_performance_drift": -0.3,
+      "bias_drift": +0.1,
+      "overall_stability": "stable"
+    }
+  },
+  
+  "compliance_certifications": {
+    "iso_27001": {
+      "certified": true,
+      "certification_date": "2024-09-15",
+      "valid_until": "2027-09-15"
+    },
+    "soc2_type2": {
+      "certified": true,
+      "certification_date": "2024-08-20",
+      "valid_until": "2025-08-20"
+    },
+    "ai_safety_certification": {
+      "certified": true,
+      "certification_date": "2024-10-20",
+      "valid_until": "2025-10-20"
+    }
+  },
+  
+  "recommendations": {
+    "immediate_actions": [
+      "Address 2 medium severity vulnerabilities from red team testing",
+      "Enhance multi-turn manipulation detection",
+      "Improve citation accuracy for current events"
+    ],
+    "short_term_improvements": [
+      "Reduce hallucination rate in current events domain",
+      "Fine-tune bias mitigation for edge cases",
+      "Expand adversarial training dataset"
+    ],
+    "long_term_enhancements": [
+      "Implement advanced fact-checking integration",
+      "Develop domain-specific safety modules",
+      "Enhance explainability of safety decisions"
+    ]
+  },
+  
+  "overall_safety_score": {
+    "composite_score": 94.7,
+    "rating": "Excellent",
+    "comparison_to_baseline": "+18.3% improvement over Helion-V1.5",
+    "industry_percentile": 92
+  }
+}